I forgot to get back on here and thank you all for your help and advice. I got the pan back on and it's leak free, thanks to your support. I'll be sure to shove shop towels in EVERY hole next time. LOL.
Also, I love that one-piece gasket, it really made the installation much easier and it takes much more torque than cork gasket could handle (thanks to it's steel core). If you are replacing your pan gasket I highly recommend them, just make sure you know whether you need the thick front seal or the thin one, and where your dipstick is of course. Mine was $27 after tax at AZ (worth every penny).