73-87chevytrucks.com

73-87 Chevy _ GMC Trucks => Electrical => Topic started by: Stewart G Griffin on December 05, 2016, 07:05:33 PM

Title: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on December 05, 2016, 07:05:33 PM
1) What are some good quality alternators?


2) What is the best alternator, money no object?
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: zieg85 on December 05, 2016, 07:25:51 PM
For starters and alternators I buy for a vehicle I plan to keep for a long time I prefer Napa stuff
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Da67goatman on December 06, 2016, 01:09:18 AM
Power requirements? 70amp? 140amp? 350amp? 500amp?  That alone will limit your options.  Belt drive also plays a part
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on December 06, 2016, 06:04:20 AM
Power requirements? 70amp? 140amp? 350amp? 500amp?  That alone will limit your options.  Belt drive also plays a part

Stock for a 4.3 and the ribbed belt.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Captain Swampy on December 06, 2016, 09:51:40 AM
I like Remy alternators. I get them from Rock Auto.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on December 06, 2016, 06:58:27 PM
Power requirements? 70amp? 140amp? 350amp? 500amp?  That alone will limit your options.  Belt drive also plays a part

i think stock alternator for an 86 4.3 was 37 amps.   Are there any disadvantages to going higher?
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: MrFiveOh on December 07, 2016, 08:16:34 AM
Power requirements? 70amp? 140amp? 350amp? 500amp?  That alone will limit your options.  Belt drive also plays a part

i think stock alternator for an 86 4.3 was 37 amps.   Are there any disadvantages to going higher?

You can get a summit 140 amp alternator, direct fir for $108. I went with DB Electric 140 amp from amazon(Prime) for $127.  I have a pretty hefty audio setup so i went with a bigger alt for that reason.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: hatzie on December 07, 2016, 08:57:12 AM
Power requirements? 70amp? 140amp? 350amp? 500amp?  That alone will limit your options.  Belt drive also plays a part

i think stock alternator for an 86 4.3 was 37 amps.   Are there any disadvantages to going higher?
Depends on the options.  It could be 37-78 Amps.
There's no downside to buying one of the higher output alternators for your rig.  Be sure the ears are clocked so it bolts up.
Title: Best alternators:
Post by: philo_beddoe on December 07, 2016, 10:00:39 PM
I like Remy alternators. I get them from Rock Auto.
Swampy, i already had my response in mind as i was scrolling down. I was going to post the exact same! Delco-Remy, rock auto. Made in USA.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: LTZ C20 on December 08, 2016, 01:43:44 AM
I get my alternators from the dealer. GM or AC Delco only, not worth my time to mess with anything else.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: hatzie on December 08, 2016, 11:02:48 AM
I get my alternators from the dealer. GM or AC Delco only, not worth my time to mess with anything else.

I've always had fairly good results from AC Delco Professional Grade remanufactured alternators from Rock Auto.  These are the same units the dealer charges 2x or 3x or 4x the price.  My diesel starters and Military electrical go to a trusted local guy.
I wouldn't touch any of the "New" Asian units.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Irish_Alley on December 08, 2016, 10:40:15 PM
wouldnt a higher amp alt cause more drag on the engine? some wont mind this but stew is constantly trying to the best mpg
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: hatzie on December 09, 2016, 02:16:58 AM
wouldnt a higher amp alt cause more drag on the engine? some wont mind this but stew is constantly trying to the best mpg
Only while the battery is low.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Irish_Alley on December 09, 2016, 03:25:56 AM
found this
With a 100amp alternator installed, we do not drive around with the alternator constantly producing 100amps.  When driving a simple car, in example a ’66 Chevelle, with no accessories switched on, stock ignition, and the battery topped off with a charge, the alternator produces only about 3amps to 5amps of current!  (No matter how powerful the alternator, output is limited according to system demands.)

And, in case you are wondering, the amount of horsepower used to spin the alternator changes with output.  When the alternators produce only a small amount of current, the horsepower drag is very small (less than 1/3 amp).  Large amount of output causes more horsepower drag (about 3 or 4 horsepower to produce 120amps output).
http://www.madelectrical.com/electricaltech/howitworks.shtml

so if the 34 amp is the same price as a 78 amp and there will be no difference in draw under normal use. then nothing will be effected from the bigger alt.
Title: Best alternators:
Post by: philo_beddoe on December 09, 2016, 10:00:39 PM
42 amp.

http://www.remyautoparts.com/Product/Details/20038
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: VileZambonie on December 10, 2016, 08:04:45 AM
You can all be brand loyal but in reality that doesn't make a lot of practical sense (for more reasons then I care to discuss right now) but what does primarily is availability on your parts. Most AP stores offer decent warranties on alternators and will have these in stock. If you think an AC Delco alternator won't let you down, think again. If you are ordering it from rockauto or the like and it decides to find the cemetery are you okay with waiting a few days for a replacement and then waiting for a credit? It sure is nice to pop two bolts and run down to the parts store and be back up and running in no time. If that doesn't matter to you then what I said is irrelevant to you but for those who daily drive and rely on your trucks, availability and warranty should be helping you decide where to buy those parts.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: FlatBlack77 on December 10, 2016, 09:47:23 AM
Very well said Vile
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: hatzie on December 10, 2016, 12:58:30 PM
You can all be brand loyal but in reality that doesn't make a lot of practical sense (for more reasons then I care to discuss right now) but what does primarily is availability on your parts. Most AP stores offer decent warranties on alternators and will have these in stock. If you think an AC Delco alternator won't let you down, think again. If you are ordering it from rockauto or the like and it decides to find the cemetery are you okay with waiting a few days for a replacement and then waiting for a credit? It sure is nice to pop two bolts and run down to the parts store and be back up and running in no time. If that doesn't matter to you then what I said is irrelevant to you but for those who daily drive and rely on your trucks, availability and warranty should be helping you decide where to buy those parts.

Very good point.

If this is your daily driver or a rig with uncommon parts like my green iron then the game changes significantly.  'Swhy I get those done by a local guy that I've known and trusted for years. 
When I brought my run of the mill Delco SI from my 85 C10 and the CS from my 2000 6.5L to him he said don't bother just get a Delco Pro series reman online and hang onto the cores.  He's had difficulty in getting parts made outside Asia for quite a while but he seems to still be able to get decent quality parts.

My 85 is my only gasoline engine pickup and is not a daily driver.  I've had fairly decent experiences with RockAuto warranty items. Three days in the unlikely event of a warranty claim isn't a deal breaker for me.  It could be for some people.  If it is change your game plan.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Irish_Alley on December 10, 2016, 03:04:12 PM
im with vile also on the parts stores and getting a replacement. back when i got my truck back on the road with the built alternator straight from the alternator shop, a month later it failed. i was about 4 hours away from that shop (it was a one wire alt and would start charging at 300 rpms). and it was the weekend so no alt shops would be open to get me back on the road by monday. luckily napa was around this town and i left all my wires for the stock alt alone so i was able to just get one from there. took the bad alt to the alternator shop where the warranty would only cover parts and he rebuilt it.

so now i drive around with this rebuilt alternator in my tool box cause im stuck with two good alternators cause
Title: Best alternators:
Post by: philo_beddoe on December 10, 2016, 10:42:55 PM
Plus avoid return shipping charges, makes sense to buy what you can local. Anyone know an AP srore that sells the delco-remy alt?
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: 75gmck25 on December 16, 2016, 03:53:35 PM
My '75 GMC had A/C and HD cooling, so the alternator was a 63 amp V-belt 10si unit.  I replaced it with a 94 amp V-belt 12si unit from a mid 80's Chevy.  Its a direct bolt on, and the only change you need to make is to upsize the charge wire from the stock 10 gauge to an 8 gauge.   I think the price on a rebuilt 94 amp unit was nearly the same as the stock 63 amp.

I also ran the charge wire directly from the alternator over to the battery positive, with a fusible link on the battery end, instead of using the starter terminal as a junction point like GM did from the factory.

Bruce
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: rich weyand on December 18, 2016, 03:22:49 PM
You probably have a 10SI on there.  It has the stamped impeller for cooling on the front.

You can switch to a 12SI with no wiring or bracket changes and go a lot higher.  90+ amps is easy.  Summit has 12SI-format alternators to 200 amps, which is way overkill, and you pay big bucks for it, so I don't recommend it.

Here's what I did:
http://forum.73-87chevytrucks.com/smforum/index.php?topic=28215.0
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on January 28, 2017, 07:49:09 PM
Need more help:

i have the hybrid belt setup of water pump and alternator having the ribbed serpentine belt.  And everything else is conventional V-belt.  The ribbed belt is, i believe 5 rib?  And the pulleys are i believe 4 grove?

Basically this setup, if you'll scroll down:
http://forum.73-87chevytrucks.com/smforum/index.php?topic=21823.15

Both AC Delco and Remy list alternators with a V-belt pulley for an 85-86 4.3 application.

Pretty much all the parts stores also list alternators with v-belts for this application.  (Even though if you search for alternator BELT on their websites, they list ribbed belt..............)

Can anyone come up with a workable part#?   The plug is at the 12:00 position.  i would like to keep it under 78amps, 63 preferable.

i know we can just change the pulley, but i don't have the tools/ability to do so now, so i would like to keep simple with a bolt on part.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on January 28, 2017, 07:51:23 PM
P.S.
i came up with AC delco 321-357, which is the part# for an 87 R10,  but does this alternator turn CW?   Did the 87 trucks have the full serpentine setup?
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: bd on January 28, 2017, 08:22:28 PM
That alternator should work fine.  It is CW rotation.  The B+ output post should be clocked the same as the adjuster bolt and the regulator plug just CCW from the post, looking from the front of the alternator.  The 87 R10 used a setup virtually identical to what 78 Chevyrado imaged.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on January 28, 2017, 10:15:26 PM
That alternator should work fine.  It is CW rotation.  The B+ output post should be clocked the same as the adjuster bolt and the regulator plug just CCW from the post, looking from the front of the alternator.  The 87 R10 used a setup virtually identical to what 78 Chevyrado imaged.

Yes, after doing a little more research, it appears that the true serpentine didn't start until 88?
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on February 09, 2017, 07:16:49 AM
For a starter, i went with REMY 28367 which was $25 at Rock auto.

Why so cheap?   i'm not complaining about the price, i am just concerned----that it may not be high quality at such a low price...?


2) it turns out that the alternator may have not been the problem, although the new one works great and i could have probably used a new one anyways.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Irish_Alley on February 09, 2017, 07:20:04 AM
stew maybe you should start with whats wrong and what test youve done so far
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on February 10, 2017, 08:00:55 PM
The starter all of a sudden last week would sometimes not crank much, after a few tries, it cranked normally.   The situation repeated itself a few times.

Battery tested good

Charging system tested bad/"underachieving", so replaced alternator with the ac delco  321-357

Starter problem still persisted.  To me, this indicates bad starter-----you try it a few times, bad crank, then on the third or fifth time normal crank etc.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: hatzie on February 14, 2017, 05:52:36 PM
Before you toss the starter...  Check the battery voltage and then all of your connections at the solenoid, battery, and alternator bracket.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on February 15, 2017, 08:33:08 PM
Update:
Yes, i checked battery voltage---good.  Connections were all good and tight.

It turned out to be the starter----i installed the reman remy and it starts fine everytime now.
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on February 20, 2017, 08:08:35 AM
http://www.delcoremy.com/The-Latest/2013/June/Reman-vs-Imitation
Title: Re: Best alternators:
Post by: Stewart G Griffin on March 11, 2017, 07:04:45 PM
You can all be brand loyal but in reality that doesn't make a lot of practical sense (for more reasons then I care to discuss right now) but what does primarily is availability on your parts. Most AP stores offer decent warranties on alternators and will have these in stock. If you think an AC Delco alternator won't let you down, think again. If you are ordering it from rockauto or the like and it decides to find the cemetery are you okay with waiting a few days for a replacement and then waiting for a credit? It sure is nice to pop two bolts and run down to the parts store and be back up and running in no time. If that doesn't matter to you then what I said is irrelevant to you but for those who daily drive and rely on your trucks, availability and warranty should be helping you decide where to buy those parts.

Well, the V-man was right;  i spent about $120 to put a reman AC delco alternator in, only to have to take it out after two weeks and put the "offbrand" autoparts store brand in that was on the 305 and 350 on.

The other thing that i didn't fully realize was that those autoparts stores remans ARE delco/remy units---it says that right on the back of the units.   So, if these remans are put back together with care, then they should be just as good as an AC delco reman.  The same rebuilders who do the autoparts store brands may even also reman them for AC delco?