I believe brand name Westin or Fey make a bumper for around $150 new, sometimes you need their brackets as well which is another $50. That puts you right at budget. Your going to be hard pressed to get a clean bumper and then paint it for your budget, especially in the north east(I know I've been looking as well to replace the chrome job I have). These bumpers are typically black,grey, or silver painted(chromed bumpers are over the $200 mark)
Maybe send Chris here a message and see what he could get in the store.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk