73-87chevytrucks.com
73-87 Chevy _ GMC Trucks => Engine/Drivetrain => Topic started by: Surfdude on May 23, 2016, 06:47:35 pm
-
Hi all,
Been lurking here and searching as I go along.
To the problem which I have found similar threads but no 'solutions'.
The truck:
1978 C10 Stepside with a 350/350 combo.
The engine was replaced at some point with a crate Goodwrench engine.
Because it is California, SMOG is required and no fudging.
It passed last year with no troubles.
No changes to the engine, no adjustments
Driven daily.
When last setup, for smog by the way:
The timing was set @ 8 degrees BTDC with vacuum removed from distributor and vacuum line plugged.
I go in for check and the tailpipe numbers are great:
HC (PPM) Max 324 Measured 128
CO (%) Max 3.80 Measured 0.05
NO (PPM) Max 2125 Measured 833
However, I failed due to timing being 63 degrees BTDC.
They grabbed a couple different lights trying to figure that out as the truck starts right up with a touch of the key.
I checked the balancer and it was correct.
I changed it anyway just because I was out of ideas.
The plugs are a nice tan color and with the vacuum advance plugged the engine sits about 20" of vacuum.
When I hook up the vacuum advance advance the gauge drops to around 12".
I realize that is a bit low but the timing is set with the vacuum advance disabled and plugged.
In any case, the engine shouldn't run at 63 BDTC, certainly not as well as it does.
I am going to try to setup a different timing mark and see if I can get them to buy that off, but I am doubtful.
I checked that the distributor mechanical advance is not stuck, it is fine.
Ideas?
Thanks in advance.
-
Maybe your balancers outer ring has spun. That's really the only thing I can think of. Mine has spun and it's about 50 degrees off. If I try to time it correctly where it's at it won't run at all. Maybe a backfire or two through the carb.
Edit: I missed where you said you replaced the balancer. I don't understand if the emissions test passed and it's running properly, why check timing.
-
i would start by verifying tdc
http://forum.73-87chevytrucks.com/smforum/index.php?topic=32085.0
-
Thank you for the replies.
I changed the harmonic balancer mostly because I couldn't think of anything else.
I bumped the engine around with #1 spark plug out until my thumb was pushed off.
TDC appeared close. If it is really so far out that 63 degrees BDTC is needed I would think it would appear obvious.
The link you posted was one of the ones I have read looking for clues, but thank you for the replies.
I don't want to get started down a rabbit hole so I am making sure I am thinking this through correctly.
The distributor timing is the relation between the crankshaft and the distributor gearing so if I jumped a cam chain there would be different problems.
And again, things were set at 8 degrees last year and I have changed nothing.
I am kicking myself for not pulling the cam cover when I had the balancer off, but I was being single-minded about things and really thinking that if I jumped a tooth that I would have been having problems such as back-firing, pinging, etc.
63 degrees, one complete piston off is 45 so that would make ~1 1/2 off in the firing order? I can't for the life of me even figure how it is running.
I cannot even see the timing mark at the moment when trying to setup the timing and advancing it until the distributor is at the stop yields about 16 degrees BTDC and really crappy running.
BTW, the title is what the smog shop wrote as a failure reason.
Thanks again.
-
No, the crank goes around twice every time around the firing order, so one piston is 90*.
Vacuum advance should be on the order of 15*, so you should read 23* at idle when set for 8* BTDC base timing.
What vacuum advance can is on it? (Numbers are stamped on the metal tang visible between the vac can and the distributor cap.)
-
Did you verify they had the inductive clamp on #1 cylinder? How were they checking the timing? At idle with vacuum advance plugged?
-
Rich,
I am not sure I am looking at the spot I understood you were asking about. There is no number stamped on the vacuum tab for the distributor. Picture enclosed.
Yes, timing checked with distributor vacuum off and plugged.
Looking at how all this is lined up, it looks like I need to move the distributor since #1 is closer to the 5 o'clock position but...how did all of this move?
TIA
-
Well, if pix 2 and 3 were taken at the same crank position, then #1 is forward, which is right. And the vac can comes off at the right angle, so that's right.
The vac can normally has a number on it, like this:
http://www.nastyz28.com/~copo/images/b28_va_can1.JPG
So that's not a stock vacuum advance canister.
But, you said the timing indications are off even though the vacuum was disconnected, so that's not it.
You didn't change the balancer or the timing tab? You should know that there are three different tab locations and balancer wheels. The crankshaft keyway at #1TDC is at 45 crankshaft degrees clockwise from straight up on all Chevy small blocks: call it 1:30 o'clock looking at the front of the engine. The three timing tab locations are 40* counterclockwise from the keyway (5* total off vertical, called 12:00), 10* counterclockwise (35* total off vertical, called 2:00, though it's more like 1:00 really), and 2* counterclockwise (about 43* off vertical, called 2:30, though it's more like 1:30 really).
If you have the wrong tab for the balancer, you could be off by 30* or 38* in your timing reading.
-
63°? Woah!
You don't have a couple of your plug wires reversed do you? Like #s 2 & 1 switched at the cap? Just for giggles run your firing order if you haven't already. 1-8-4-3-6-5-7-2.
-
I'd just get the degree stickers for the crank pulley and fake it
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
I'd just get the degree stickers for the crank
Nothing like a problem solver!
-
Putting the degree stickers on the balancer is my last 'go to' solution, that seemed to be the way that this was solved every other time it is brought up on other boards. My concern is the state is pretty finicky about the smog stuff. They check that gas caps are in place and holding pressure.
Pix #2 & #3 were taken at the same time.
I don't know any history of this engine. Obviously at some point before it was parked for a couple decades, the engine was changed to the current Goodwrench engine. The distributor is marked as an ACCEL "all 50 state legal" distributor. It makes me wonder what they did to the previous engine that they couldn't even save the distributor. The timing tab is the same one that was on it. I saw that conversation on another board about timing tab location, where would I get a 'different' timing tab?
Engineer, I will check firing order again. The truck runs smooth with nice acceleration. It won't win any races except perhaps except bicycles but I don't drive it for that. That is why I have a motorcycle.
One of the questions I hope to be able to answer is how did the timing move so much? When the title was transferred, I had to smog the engine and while the numbers were not as good as they are now (due to sitting, I'll wager) the timing was at 8 degrees BDTC for it to pass. The P.O. thought he could remove smog, but the car has to be pre-1975 in order to ignore smog in this state. :(
I had to work out the vacuum lines and other issues that this board was invaluable in finding the information to get the ol' girl running. After I set it all up, I haven't moved any settings. This has just been a DD for picking up kids and teaching one of the kids to drive :o Speaking of which gotta run to get them to their various sports.
I do appreciate all of the help, being able to think out loud does help such as remembering that I don't have a 2-stroke engine (thanks Rich).
-
Do you have a timing light and have you verified their readings?
-
Do you have a timing light and have you verified their readings?
I have a basic timing light not one with regressive timing abilities. I can say that the timing mark is not currently visible at the tab.
I see that the distributor is at 6 o'clock position when currently at TDC. I can move the gearing so it is at the 5 position where # 1 is located to see if that helps although I don't see how it could jump teeth during normal driving.
If it fixes the immediate problem I can come back to the why, I suppose.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
Does it run OK ?
Only problem is with what the smog station thinks the timing is set at ?
If you actually had that kind of timing I don't think the engine would even run
If that's the only issue. I'd slap the sticker on and let them see what they want to see
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
The local Pep Boys and AZ had did not know what timing tape was even when I showed them pictures on my phone. So I would need to order some, that is the primary reason I am holding off doing that as the first solution. I have until the 11th of June, then I get to pay full price again for a retest. Gotta love this state and it ability to raise revenue. I have a brother in law who lives in Vegas, I may just register the vehicle in Nevada and be done with it.
I had initial thoughts of doing a LS swap but I have to be careful, I would need to pass the emissions of the year of the engine. So, a 2005-ish engine means I would have to meet all of the ODB II requirements. Not really feasible for a truck that is being used to haul surfboards and bikes around. I even put the vinyl floor in it so I can get the sand out easier. 8)
I will let keep this up until it is resolved one way or another.
-
Basic starting point: The engine won't lie to you. The timing wheel might, the timing tab might, but the engine won't.
So if that's where it runs good, and you're not getting any knocking, you are between 4 and 20 degrees BTDC.
Period.
OK, so back to basics. Line up the timing mark at 0 BTDC as in the pics, and use an inspection mirror to see where the keyway is on the crankshaft. It should be at 45* as seen from the front -- between 1 and 2 on the clock. That can't lie either. If it is straight up, or straight out at 3 o'clock, then your timing wheel/tab combination is 45 degrees off. I suspect you will find the keyway is at 3 o'clock or more when the mark is lined up.
-
Rich,
I know the answer to this one. The keyway is at the 12 o'clock position when the timing mark is at 0 on the tab
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
-
Order a tape from summit or jegs
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
-
third picture looks like you're closer to firing 8 than 1 but if you have the #1 plug wire in that cap position and followed through with the 8,4,3,6,5,7,2 in succession that shouldn't make a difference in what a timing light would show at the crank.
-
Rich,
I know the answer to this one. The keyway is at the 12 o'clock position when the timing mark is at 0 on the tab
So there you go. Wrong timing wheel or wrong tab. The #1 cylinder is at TDC when the keyway is at 45* CW from straight up when viewed from the front. (The keyway lines up with the #1 rod throw.) That is true of all GM V8s ever.
So the timing mark is off 45*.
But then it should look like you are running 40 or so degrees AFTER TDC, because the timing mark is going to have to move another 45* past the tab before you hit the actual TDC.
-
Let me ask you. Is your current timing tab at 12:00 on the balancer wheel? That is, is it on top of the engine in the front? Sounds like the balancer wheel is one for the side mounted timing tab, which is more like 1:30 on the balancer wheel, while your tab is on the top, so they aren't for the same setup.
So how did you get here? Lessee. The original timing wheel was set up for the top-mounted tab, so you set it there and it runs fine. Then the balancer slips because the rubber is old and hardened. So you know this could be the issue, so you replace the balancer with the much more common one that needs the side tab, and now you can't get the thing to time properly with the new balancer on the old tab.
Solution: Move the tab, or get the rarer balancer for the 12:00 tab.
-
Note notation on this one: "w/Center Timing Mark".
http://www.jegs.com/i/Proform/778/66509/10002/-1
Note this one doesn't mention the timing mark, so it will be in the earlier 2:00 position.
http://www.jegs.com/i/Proform/778/66510/10002/-1
I would move/replace the tab.
-
Went back and looked at pic #2. Looks like that is the 2:00 position, same as mine. I could reproduce this picture.
Hmm. Timing mark is still wrong, though. Needs keyway at 45*.
I used this widget over the balancer to keep from relying on the balancer for the timing mark.
http://www.jegs.com/i/Proform/778/66518BKC/10002/-1
-
Do you have a timing light and have you verified their readings?
I have a basic timing light not one with regressive timing abilities. I can say that the timing mark is not currently visible at the tab.
I see that the distributor is at 6 o'clock position when currently at TDC. I can move the gearing so it is at the 5 position where # 1 is located to see if that helps although I don't see how it could jump teeth during normal driving.
If it fixes the immediate problem I can come back to the why, I suppose.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk
It's irrelevant. Either your balancer is incorrect or your timing tab is incorrect or you are putting the inductive pickup on the wrong wire.
-
I am a bit confused. I went back and reread the OP. How were you able to set the initial timing at 8° BTDC if the balancer was incorrect for the timing tab?
-
I think the original balancer slipped after it was set, then he installed a new balancer, but I think it is the wrong one. So now he can't set the timing from that new mark. He's 45* off (crankshaft keyway at 12:00 with timing mark on 0).
-
I think the original balancer slipped after it was set, then he installed a new balancer, but I think it is the wrong one. So now he can't set the timing from that new mark. He's 45* off (crankshaft keyway at 12:00 with timing mark on 0).
The end of the saga;. The short version is that I used a bit of HS geometry and re-marked the balancer 45 degrees earlier with engine tuned for max vacuum and no knock. The new mark hit 8 degrees with the light. I passed smog today so time to move on. Thank you for the help.
On a side note, I was able to pick up a fender with inner and a new tailgate with CHEVROLET stamped for great price this weekend. Poor guy had dropped a 6 liter and 4160 in his 77 stepside and had just got out of the body shop the day before when he was T-ed in the driver side fender. Truck all blocked and primered. Frame bent but no one hurt. His rust free cab may be available.
Sent from my Nexus 7 using Tapatalk
-
The end of the saga;. The short version is that I used a bit of HS geometry and re-marked the balancer 45 degrees earlier with engine tuned for max vacuum and no knock. The new mark hit 8 degrees with the light. I passed smog today so time to move on. Thank you for the help.
There ya go! Thanks for letting us know.