It's all personal preferrence. If you like driving a standard transmission, it pretty much the same, except no clutch. I have a manual valve body in the th350 in my '71. Using the ratchet shifter it's not too bad. But I would not do it with a column shifter, overshifting would be too easy without a positive stop like the ratchet shifter provides. In fact, I have considered having it taken out. Shifting up and down can get on my nerves a bit at times.