I prefer a 31x10.5 and bfg a/t t/a tire on a 4x4, but that's just my preference. I had a set of rims like your 1st pic, I got them completely trashed for 40.00 for the set. I wet sanded and polished (a lot)and the shine did come back, they looked almost new. btw when you do get them make sure they don't install the wheel weights on the outside of the rims.