All Classified forums require a Site Supporter subscription. It is only $25 per year and you can buy and sell whatever you like on the forum. To become a Site Supporter, go to Your Profile and select "Paid Subscriptions."
So the website and the store had two different part numbers. I brought the spindle in to make sure the second set fit. Whats really annoying is that the website has the same inner diameter for both bearings, but obviously one is no good. Could've saved me a lot of time. Whatever, as long as it gets done.