All Classified forums require a Site Supporter subscription. It is only $25 per year and you can buy and sell whatever you like on the forum. To become a Site Supporter, go to Your Profile and select "Paid Subscriptions."
I have heard of mufflers for a 2.5 system actually having less than 2.5" internals. I'm pretty sure either one would work good, but I'd like which ever would be deeper sounding, if it would make a difference at all.
Yeah it'll sound different.... because you'll have leaks all around your .250" gap around your pipe connections Just get the muffler that fits your pipes.