If its dividing airflow between the vent and defrost something is holding up the second trap door. It's either debris like beastie said or its not getting enough vacuum to the diaphragm. Also check that the hinge pin on the door didn't pop out of the hole in the duct. If you tear it all apart so that you can see it, you can run the truck and work the switch to see and hear what its doing. My ductwork was all different kinds of wrong when I got it, and filled with mice, but I found almost a dollar in change and a handful of .22 shells when I took it apart.