Use a lithium base grease such as Sta-Lube General Purpose (greenish brown), Sta-Lube Sta-Plex (red), or Lubriplate Type A (white). Super Lube Synthetic (clear) will work, too, but may need to be reapplied more frequently than the lithium base greases. Generally, I do not recommend mixing greases that are known to be different. Specifically, don't mix lithium base and calcium base greases - results can vary but often cause unpredictable changes in viscosity, lubricity and sometimes causes caking. That said, the Sta-Lube General Purpose grease is probably most like the factory grease used during assembly.